Average Rating:
Ameda Breast Pump Reviews
"I've been really happy with this purchase. Perfect for mamas that are mainly nursing and want to use this as a back up. Love the design for the one handed pump. Easy to clean and you can use most other brands of bottles..."
Average Rating:
Avent Breast Pump Reviews
"This has all the features I needed. It is comfortable and easy to use and get used to. It's battery pack for pumping on the go is great too! Easy to clean and disassemble/reassemble. I definitely recommend it..."
Average Rating:
Bailey Medical Breast Pump Reviews
"I would recommend this product to anyone. It’s affordable, light weight, convenient and did I say light weight. With all the baby gear I have to tote around it’s relieving to have a manageable pumping system that is so easy to carry. This breast pump comes with everything... "
Average Rating:
Medela Breast Pump Reviews
"I thought since the hospital used Medela that it has to be a great product Boy was I wrong It is loud Heavy and tends to leak in to the lines. Plus the plastic seems cheaper then other pumps. This product was a pure disapointment. Was so painful. Im actually going to find myself another one for my second child..."
Average Rating:
Playtex Breast Pump Reviews
"I purchased the Embrace because a friend told me that it was supposedly a good one. Having never used a pump before I didnt know what to expect. My Playtex Embrace is a very comfortable breast pump. It does have a few design flaws in my opinion..."
Average Rating:
Simplisse Breast Pump Reviews
"Prior to trying the Simplisse, I had two other manual pumps, but it was always too painful for me to pump a bottle for my little girl. I'd usually resort to manual hand expression after pumping for only a few minutes. I'm guessing that the suck-and-release that they mention the other kinds of pumps use was the problem..."
Average Rating:
Hygeia Breast Pump Reviews
"I originally purchased a manual pump, but I soon realized that it was taking up more time than I liked so I thought an electric pump would do the trick. I chose the Hygeia Enjoye because it seemed to be the best option for me since it comes with a 3 year warranty..."
Average Rating:
The First Years Breast Pump Reviews
"I was able to use this pump for a few months before it began to give me problems. The motor stopped working, but on the bright side when I called First Years about it, they sent me out a new one so I’m still able to keep pumping. I find that the soft breast shields..."
If you are in the early stages of pump shopping you may find it helpful to read Choosing a Breast Pump before reading our customers' views of each pump.
Once you know the type of pump you need, reviews by other moms can help identify each pump's advantages and shortcomings. You can slo see how different pumps measure up to one another in our Breast Pump Comparisons
Breast Pump Features
Be sure that you know which of the following pump features are most important to you, and which you are willing to give up before you begin to evaluate how each of the different pump models will meet your pumping needs.
Pump Aspects to Take Notice of When Reading Reviews:
- Effectiveness – Is determined by how well the pump is able to draw milk from the breast. Generally, the closer a pump’s cycling speed (how many sucks per minute) and vacuum strength are able to mimic a nursing baby the more effective it will be at expressing milk.
- Type of Pumping – Single pumps, both manual and electric, allow you to pump one breast at a time. Double pumps give you the option to express milk from both breasts at the same time, which helps to stimulate milk production and shortens the time needed to pump.
- Comfort Level – If the pump is uncomfortable, it will be very challenging for you to use. Being able to adjust the pump’s cycle speed and vacuum strength is the key to achieving an acceptable comfort level.
- Portability – How much does the pump weigh? Is it difficult to carry from place to place? Does it come with a bag or tote for packing motor and extra accessories? Does it provide a compartment or cooler for storing and cooling expressed milk?
- Power Options – Several power options are available for electric pumps including AC adapter, battery power and car adapter. If you travel often or will need to pump in various locations, having alternative power options may be a necessity for you. While manual pumping can be tiresome, it can be a lifesaver when other power options are not available.
- Motor Noise Level – A noisy pump motor can be a distraction to some moms while some moms worry that discretion will be compromised if those near by will be able to hear the pump.
- Durability – Each pump is designed to handle a certain amount of pumping. Some pumps are for occasional use while others can be used several times a day everyday for a year or more. Choosing to use a pump designed for occasional pumping several times each day may cause the pump motor as well as other parts to wear out quickly.
Breast Pump Pros & Cons
Be sure that you know which of the following pump features are most important to you, and whic h you are willing to give up before you begin to evaluate how each of the different pump models will meet your pumping needs.
- Ameda |
- Avent |
- Bailey Medical |
- Medela |
- Playtex |
- Hygeia |
- The First Years |
- Simplisse
Pros
- Trusted name in hospitals for more than 50 years. Pumps are recommended by doctors and lactation consultants.
- Ameda was the first company to develop an electric breast pump.
- All Ameda pumps use the FDA approved HygieniKit Collection System, which maintains the purity of expressed milk.
- Pump can be used with any brand of standard bottle.
Cons
- Not compatible with wide neck bottles.
- Replacement parts and storage products can be difficult to find locally.
Pros
- One of the most preferred infant feeding brands in America.
- Breast pumps and feeding lines work together to allow you to pump, store and feed with an Avent bottle or cup.
- Isis Manual pump has been the most popular manual pump for more than a decade.
- Electric line of pumps offer infinitely variable speed and suction settings that you are able to control.
Cons
- Pumps are not compatible with other brands of bottles. Avent bottles or cups have to be used for pumping.
- Isis iQ Duo does not offer battery operation. Vehicle adapter is not compatible with Isis iQ Uno.
- Does not offer larger breastshield sizes.
Pros
- The Nurture III has been a trusted breast pump for more than 20 years.
- Only personal use electric pump approved safe for multiple users by the FDA.
- One of the most affordable double electric breast pumps available on the market.
Cons
- Manual cycling of pump can make it difficult for mom to continue other activities while pumping.
- Does not offer battery operation.
Pros
- Preferred breast pump brand in America for more than 20 years.
- Recommended by hospitals and lactation consultants.
Cons
- Pumps do not operate on a closed collection system; milk can leak into pump tubing.
- Pump motors are fixed into pump bags.
Pros
- Has been an infant feeding product manufacturer for more than 40 years.
- All breast pump models have soft breast cups that provide gentle, massaging stimulation.
- Pumps are compatible with most brands of bottles.
Cons
- Breast pumps have not been on the market for a long time.
Pros
- All electric breast pumps are FDA approved for multiple users.
- 3 year manufacturer’s warranty on all electric breast pumps.
- Total Compatibility Guarantee allows you to try pump for 21 days.
Cons
- Brand is relatively new to the market.
- Replacement parts may not be widely available in local retail markets.
Pros
- Flexi-fit shields ensure proper fit and comfortable pumping.
- Full line of breast pumps available – manual, single electric and double electric.
- Offers some of the most affordable electric breast pump packages on the market.
Cons
- Brand does not offer larger breastshield sizes.
- Pumps do not operate on a closed system which allows milk to be sucked into pump tubing and motors.
- Electric pumps have 90 Day warranty whereas most electric pumps from other manufacturers have a full year warranty.
Pros
- Pumps offer more comfortable and natural milk expression.
- Full line of nursing products available including pumps, sterilizing products, breast care and milk storage options.
- Endorsed by lactation consultants and moms
Cons
- Brand is relatively new to the market.
- Replacement parts may not be widely available in local retail markets.
